• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Sussex Coffee Company – Award-Winning Cozy Coffee Shop in Sussex, NJ

Sussex Coffee Company in Sussex, NJ, is a cozy gem renowned for expertly crafted espresso and inventive seasonal drinks. The friendly staff, including Sebastian and Alexis, create a warm, welcoming atmosphere that feels like a local haven. Their unique menu highlights irresistible offerings like the “chocolate covered strawberry” iced latte and decadent summer specials such as the Summer Break Mocha & Coconut and Fire Fly White Chocolate with marshmallow and caramel. Clean, reasonably priced, and rich in flavor, Sussex Coffee Company is more than just a coffee stop—it’s a memorable experience that keeps you coming back for its quality and charm.

Sussex Coffee Company at a glance

  • Address 22 Main St, Sussex, NJ 07461, United States
  • Phone +1 862-351-6258
  • Restaurant type Coffee shop .
  • Popular for Breakfast , Solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Sussex Coffee Company: Reviews & Ratings

Kait Darling
5

This place is absolutely a hidden gem. We happened to be in the area and looked up local coffee shops to visit. Based on the reviews we chose this place and we are very happy with our choice! Sebastian is an absolute sweetheart and knows how to properly make espresso drinks, which is hard to find these days. That atmosphere of the shop itself is so cute and cozy. 10/10 and we will definitely be back if we happen to be around this area again. I can see why they won “best coffee I’m Sussex.”

Nicholas MIller
5

OH. MY. GOD. Went and stopped by for a last minute coffee. This was my first time and Alexis helped me out, sweetest young lady. She answered all my questions and made the most delectable cup of joe!!! Can’t recommend this place more. MUST VISIT!! I will definitely be coming back!!

Julie Olinger
5

Amazing local business! I got the “chocolate covered strawberry” iced latte after being recommended it by a friend, it was amazing! Safe to say I will be back! The two people at the counter were also very friendly! Thank you!

Joshua Rainbabar
5

I can’t say enough good things about Sussex Coffee Company! Every visit feels like a little treat, and their summer menu absolutely knocks it out of the park. I tried the Summer Break Mocha & Coconut, and it’s pure magic—rich chocolate, creamy coconut, and just the right amount of sweetness. The Fire Fly White Chocolate, Marshmallow & Caramel is like dessert in a cup; the flavors are decadent but perfectly balanced, and every sip makes you feel like a kid again. Then there’s the Shore Thing Strawberry & Vanilla—so fresh and bright, it tastes like summer itself in a cup. The shop itself is cozy and welcoming, and the staff are always friendly and happy to chat about their drinks. Plus, their rewards system through the Joe app makes it easy to earn perks while enjoying all these amazing flavors. Every visit feels special, and I keep finding myself coming back just to try the next seasonal creation. Sussex Coffee Company isn’t just coffee—it’s an experience, and their summer specials make it a must-visit.

Taylor M
4

Good coffee place. Friendly staff. Very clean with reasonable prices. I got a frappè. Very good except ice was not blended too well. Ended up with large ice cubes at bottom of the drink.

Helen mecke
5

truly amazed by this amazing service , the barista helped me decide on what coffee to drink and my gosh was it amazing. i was also able to try samples of their new refreshers . watermelons cucumber mint was amazing . 10/10 will return and be sure to ask for alexis !

Stefan G.
5

I love this little coffee shop! The owners are the most amazing people! The drinks are creative and always taste so good! I bought this cute coffee mug from them and it's the perfect addition to our home decor! You guys are the best! <3

Location

  • Sussex Coffee Company
    Sussex Coffee Company
    22 Main St, Sussex, NJ 07461, United States Hotline: +1 862-351-6258

Nestled in the heart of Sussex, New Jersey, Sussex Coffee Company is a remarkable haven for coffee lovers seeking both quality and charm. This local gem stands out not just for its expertly crafted espresso drinks but also for its warm, inviting atmosphere that instantly feels like a home away from home. The baristas here, such as Sebastian and Alexis, exhibit genuine passion and expertise—transforming each cup into an experience rather than a mere beverage. Their mastery in creating balanced, flavorful coffee is a rarity in today’s fast-paced cafe culture.

What truly elevates Sussex Coffee Company are their inventive seasonal offerings and personalized customer care. From the decadent Fire Fly White Chocolate, Marshmallow & Caramel to the bright and refreshing Shore Thing Strawberry & Vanilla, every drink resonates with thoughtful craftsmanship and rich flavor layers. Their summer menu captures the essence of the season effortlessly, turning simple coffee breaks into memorable moments. The chocolate-covered strawberry iced latte is a standout that leaves a lasting impression with its perfect harmony of sweetness and smooth coffee.

The ambiance complements the beverage selection perfectly. Cozy and charming, the space encourages relaxed conversation and quiet enjoyment. Coupled with friendly staff who welcome questions and share their coffee knowledge, Sussex Coffee Company fosters a sense of community and genuine hospitality. Even those seeking quick, reliable coffee finds—like a well-made frappè—will appreciate the attention to detail and clean, well-maintained environment.

Sussex Coffee Company is more than a coffee shop; it is a thoughtfully curated experience that rewards repeat visits with fresh seasonal creations and a loyalty program through the Joe app. This ensures every coffee enthusiast feels valued and eager to discover what comes next. For anyone in Sussex or passing through, this spot demands a stop—a place where every sip tells a story of care, skill, and local pride.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
  • Service options
    • Kerbside pickup
    • No-contact delivery
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Payments
    • Credit cards